Unknown to her tiny town of Deep Haven, Isadora Presley spends her nights as Miss Foolish Heart,
 the star host of a syndicated talk radio show. Millions tune in to hear her advice on dating and falling in love, unaware that shes never really done either. Issys ratings soar when it seems shes falling in love on-air with a caller. A caller she doesnt realize lives right next door. 
Caleb Knight served a tour of duty in Iraq and paid a steep price. The last thing he wants is pity, so he hides his disability and moves to Deep Haven to land his dream job as the high school football coach. When his beautiful neighbor catches his eye, in a moment of desperation he seeks advice from My Foolish Heart, the show that airs before his favorite sports broadcast. 
Before he knows it, Caleb finds himself drawn to the hostand more confused than ever. Is his perfect love the woman on the radio . . . or the one next door?